Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Co-Parenting, Control and Food Wars

This is an interesting article that shows how seemingly "minor" conflicts in post-divorce parenting can become World War III custody battles. In this case the mom believed the father should lose custody because he packed the child a go-gurt and doritos type of lunch rather than a vegetarian, whole foods lunch. As a family law attorney I have seen how conflicts between parenting styles can escalate into control issues, post-divorce. These conflicts, while purportedly pursued because of a concern for the child's best interests, almost never end up resulting in the child's best interests being met. The battle between the parents, itself, wreaks havoc on the child and is generally far more emotionally and physically detrimental to the child than the occasional twinkie, bottle of soda, or slice of white bread. This is not to say that I don't agree wholeheartedly with parents who feed their children a whole foods, natural vegetarian diet, or some version thereof. I understand that the desire to feed the child this type of diet is from a genuine belief that the child should have, and benefits from, such a diet. This is even more true when the child's diet was structured in this way during the marriage. It is not about controlling the other parent, it is about a desire to continue to raise the child in the same manner that the child was raised during the marriage. It is upsetting to parents to lose the control over raising their child in the manner that had been previously established and either actively or passively agreed upon by both parents.
That said, for the sake of the child, food should not be the focus of a custody battle (unless, of course, the child's life depends upon sticking to a certain diet, then it is wholeheartedly in the child's best interest that both parents continue to enforce the diet). When parents separate they must be prepared to relinquish some of the day to day control over raising their child. Even if they don't believe that the other parent's methods are the best for the child, they must look at the big picture before considering engaging in a long, expensive, and heartbreaking custody battle over what the judges will most likely consider minor issues.
I want to leave you with one thought, though, regarding a negative perception you may have about this particular mother. Ask yourself, if she were complaining that the father now engages in corporal punishment, despite never having done so during the marriage and if she told you that they had both agreed not to spank their children during the marriage, would you find yourself more sympathetic to her plight?

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Military Divorce and the 20-20-20 Rule

I have a long family history of military involvement. The Pennsylvania Army National Guard, in particular, is a favorite military choice of many of my relatives. Others have joined the Marines, Air Force and Navy. My family has served here, in the Gulf War, in World War II, in Vietnam and recently my brother served three tours in Iraq with the Marines. I am proud of them all and thankful for their dedicated service.
As a divorce attorney, I am often asked about military benefits and what a former spouse may or may not enjoy when the divorce is finalized. Often the military retirement package is the most substantial asset in the marriage. In general, a military spouse will be entitled to some portion of military retirement. The portion of entitlement is based on the servicemember's years of military service, the years of the marriage, and how many years of service overlap the marriage.
Health insurance may also be available to former spouses and entitlement is determined by a calculation called the 20-20-20 Rule. If you have been married for 20 years, your spouse has been in the military for at least 20 years, and you have 20 years of marriage overlapping the 20 years of service, then the former spouse is entitled to the same benefits as the servicemember spouse - meaning health care and full commissary benefits. If there have been 20 years of service, and 20 years of marriage, but only 15 years of marriage overlap the service years, the former spouse is entitled to health care for a year after the divorce is finalized.
There are other rules and benefits to be aware of if you are getting a divorce and your spouse is in the military. I encourage you to find out what you are entitled to before you sign any divorce paperwork or go into a courtroom.

Divorce, Housing & the Economy

I have been hearing buzz that more and more "separating" or divorcing couples have decided to remain living together due to the economic infeasibility of maintaining two households given the current economy. While it is not ideal for unhappy couples to continue to remain under the same household unless they can set their differences aside, especially when there are children involved, ideal and reality seem to have parted ways. However, even couples with children who just cannot continue living together can find creative ways to manage two households. One solution could be to retain the marital residence for the sake of the children and also rent an inexpensive small efficiency or one bedroom apartment. The children could continue to reside in the marital residence, thereby preserving their familiar lifestyle, friends, location, while the parents rotate between the apartment and the house. It is certainly something to consider.

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Rights of First Refusal in Custody

Good idea or nightmare waiting to happen? Some couples have included provisions in their custody agreement that the non-custodial parent has a right of first refusal to exercise custody of the children when the custodial parent needs to leave the children with a sitter. The benefit is that the children get to see the other parent more than otherwise provided for in the couple's standard custody arrangement and, generally, the cost of a babysitter is avoided.

The difficult part is trying to figure out when such a right of refusal should kick in and how do you enforce it? This would be a personal preference and depend on your own schedules, the distance between the parents, the children's ages, etc. Make sure you consider that to some extent the non-custodial parent may become privy to far more of the custodial parent's social life than desirable (by either party!). If you agree to a right of first refusal provision for each time you must leave the children with a sitter for, say, longer than three (3) hours, be prepared to have to call the non-custodial parent almost each and every time that you go out on a date or socialize with friends. If you agree to a right of first refusal for anytime you leave the children overnight, you may effectively cut out the children's opportunity to stay with Grandma for the night. One parent's experience may be of interest to you. I do not know this parent and did not have any involvement with the case, but thought that his story may be somewhat typical of what can go wrong and why significant thought should go into the wording of any Agreement. The advice offered by the posters is their thoughts only and my directing you to the page is not intended to be considered legal advice from me.